Ratings and reviews
Old Tool Tavern Photos
Hours
| Monday | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
| Thursday | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
| Friday | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
| Saturday | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
| Sunday | 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM |
Old Tool Tavern Reviews
Our family was in the area camping at Allegheny and we stumbled across this place. We order wings and bunch of aps. Everything was delish! Tavern tots were a hit! Our server Sharon was so nice and accommodating with our 2 year old son who is always on the move. To top it off, they are Bills fans!! GO BILLS!
We where in vacation from Indiana just happened to find this place on line, we were a little worried about where it was at because we were pulling a 5th wheel camper but got there huge parking lot no problems We ordered pizza and wings, and beer of course, very good, wish that place was at home
We were visiting the Amish Trail and were ready for some food. This place looked good so we came on in. There were four of us (all from Utah) and we got a variety of food. Loaded Tots, mozzarella sticks, a Ruben and seasoned waffle fries, a grilled Bologna sandwich with a side of tots, chicken cordon blue with a side salad, and a crispy chicken salad dipped (medium hot sauce). Everything was amazing!!!! No one single complaint from a group that can be picky. The Chicken was not dry, the food was served promptly and our server was friendly. At the end I decided to find out what they offered for dessert. They had a lemon cake (not made on site). We decided to get one piece and share it. It was soooo good we had to get another slice. Added bonus it was only like 2 bucks. Anyway, go eat there because it was fabulous! The owner of even came out to meet us and gave us some souvenir cups.
Welcoming and always bending over backward to make things as best they can under the restrictions. The food has definitely NOT suffered! Great burgers and (how can you do it?) the BEST HUGE SALADS!!! Super place for a quick bite or a full on meal! Highly recommend!
The food is great, especially the prime rib with mushrooms, peppers and onions but terrible ambiance. No decor and very boring atmosphere. It's like eating at a school cafeteria. I wish they would put in some pictures on the walls, plants ( some color ) but maybe it's meant to be that way. It's excellent food and service
Awesome addition to East Randolph. I've been several times. Never had a bad meal. Great wings, burgers, and fish fry. Big dog burger is my favorite. Salad bar is a nice touch.
My friend Lexy suggested we take the ride here and it was a great idea! Brand new place in what used to be a moose Lodge. Really nice. Best food in Randolph. Amazing Philly. Great wings. Yummy big burger. Way better than mjs and nicer inside. Going to start taking cards in a week.
This place is phenomenal, you wouldn't even recognize the building if you knew what was there before. Major overhaul, basically gutted and rebuilt. It's so nice! Limited bar menu for food right now until after labor day. Food was AMAZING! Open 365 days a year. Indoor and outdoor areas, pool, darts, arcade, restaurant, and huge bar with amazing mixologists. Very reasonable prices and it's huge inside! You need to check it out!
Old Tool Tavern
Located at 114 School St, Randolph, NY, Old Tool Tavern stands out as a must-visit destination for both locals and visitors. Known for its hearty menu, laid-back ambiance, and attentive service, this restaurant combines comfort with excellent food in a way that keeps guests coming back for more.
A Tasty and Diverse Menu to Satisfy Every Craving
Whether you're in the mood for a quick snack or a full dinner, Old Tool Tavern has something for everyone. The appetizers are a fan favorite, featuring classic comfort foods like Mozzarella Sticks, Onion Rings, and Jalapeno Poppers. The deep-fried mushrooms are a standout, offering a deliciously crispy bite that pairs perfectly with a cold drink. The Pizza Logs are a popular choice, ideal for sharing with friends or enjoying as a solo treat.
When it comes to the main course, Old Tool Tavern excels with a variety of pizzas, including the Buffalo Chicken pizza and the unique Bacon Cheeseburger Tool Box pizza, both packed with flavor. The Hawaiian Pizza adds a tropical twist, while the White Pizza offers a lighter, creamy alternative. If you're craving something heartier, the Beer Battered Fish Dinner and Prime Rib Dinner are perfect choices, offering a satisfying portion of well-cooked, flavorful meat. For those looking for a lighter option, the Grilled Chicken Salad and Side Salad are ideal.
Families with children will appreciate the kid-friendly menu, which includes favorites like Chicken Tenders, Grilled Cheese, and Pizza Logs, catering to even the pickiest eaters.
An Inviting Atmosphere with Great Service
What sets Old Tool Tavern apart is not just its food but also its welcoming environment. With a variety of services designed to ensure a comfortable dining experience, including takeout, private lot parking, and waiter service, the tavern accommodates both small and large groups with ease. The moderate noise level creates a lively yet relaxed setting, perfect for enjoying a meal with friends, family, or even strangers.
The tavern also prides itself on offering many vegetarian options, ensuring that everyone can find something they enjoy, regardless of dietary preferences.
What Customers Are Saying About Old Tool Tavern
Customer reviews highlight not only the great food but also the personable staff and the overall vibe of the place. One customer, Libbie V., mentioned, "Really great people! The drinks were perfect, the pizza delicious, and the patrons lively and fun. The owner is personable (it doesn't hurt that he's handsome) and his staff are all very engaged. I love this place!" This feedback speaks to the warmth and energy that permeate the atmosphere at Old Tool Tavern.
Another happy customer, Jordan D., shared their experience: "Our family was in the area camping at Allegheny and we stumbled across this place. We ordered wings and a bunch of appetizers. Everything was delish! Tavern tots were a hit! Our server Sharon was so nice and accommodating with our 2-year-old son, who is always on the move. To top it off, they are Bills fans!! GO BILLS!" This review reflects the tavern’s family-friendly nature and attention to detail when it comes to customer service.
For visitors like Michael P., who were traveling from Indiana, Old Tool Tavern was a pleasant surprise: "We were on vacation from Indiana and just happened to find this place online. We were a little worried about where it was at because we were pulling a 5th-wheel camper, but we got there with no problems. The huge parking lot was great, and the food was excellent. We ordered pizza and wings, and of course, beer. Wish that place was at home!" The ample parking and friendly service were major pluses for these out-of-town guests.
A Convenient Location with Top-Notch Services
Old Tool Tavern has a lot to offer beyond just the food. Its private parking lot ensures that guests won’t have to worry about finding a spot, which is especially convenient for larger groups or those traveling from out of town. The restaurant also offers takeout for those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home, making it even more accessible. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or planning a longer stay with friends, Old Tool Tavern has the facilities and service to make your visit enjoyable.
From its diverse and mouthwatering menu to the engaging and personable service, Old Tool Tavern truly offers a dining experience that is hard to beat in the Randolph, NY area. Whether you're a local or just passing through, it’s a place you won’t want to miss.
Really great people! The drinks were perfect, the pizza delicious and the patrons lively and fun. The owner is personable ( it doesn't hurt that he's handsome) and his staff are all very engaged. I love this place!